How to Read a LiDAR Reflectance Target Test Report (and What to Ask For Before You Order)

A reflectance target is only as good as the number printed for it. If a panel sold as 10% really reflects 12% at your laser wavelength, every range and intensity result measured against it carries that error, and nothing in your own data will reveal it.

The test report is where that number is proven.

A reflectance target test report should show, for the individual panel you received, the measured reflectance at your LiDAR wavelength, the measurement geometry, the reference standard it traces to, and how uniform the surface is across the panel.

This article walks through eight checks, using a real Calibvision sample report as the example. You can download the full report and read along.

What a Reflectance Target Test Report Contains

Most reports follow the same order. Table 1 lists the sections, what each one tells you, and what our sample shows. The sample covers two small diffuse reflectance targets (204 × 140 mm) measured from 380 to 1000 nm.

SectionWhat it tells youIn the sample report
Test summaryWhich units, what range, the headline result2 units with serial numbers, 380–1000 nm, means of 53.26% and 53.27%
Reference standard and traceabilityWhat the measurement was compared againstReference white calibrated by the National Institute of Metrology, China (NIM)
Equipment and methodInstrument, geometry, procedure8° integrating sphere, quartz halogen source, 10 nm interval
Measurement gridWhere on the surface it was measured9 positions in a 3 × 3 grid
Spectral dataReflectance at each wavelength and position63 wavelengths × 9 positions per unit
Uniformity summaryThe spread across the surfaceLargest deviation 0.15 points from the mean
Conformance statementPass or fail against the stated tolerancePass
Table 1. Sections of a reflectance target test report, with values from the Calibvision sample report.

Eight Checks Before You Accept a Report

1. The serial number matches your panel

A report is evidence only for the unit it was measured on. Look for a serial number on the report and the same number on the panel label.

“Typical” or batch data tell you what the coating usually does. They do not tell you what your panel does. In the sample, each of the two units has its own data table and its own mean: 53.26% and 53.27%.

2. The wavelength range covers your laser

Reflectance changes with wavelength. In the sample report, the same surface reads 50.86% at 420 nm and 54.20% at 900 nm, a spread of more than three points on one panel. A value measured in visible light cannot simply be carried over to 905 nm or 1550 nm.

WavelengthMean of 9 positionsLowest positionHighest position
450 nm51.21%51.04%51.39%
550 nm52.89%52.84%52.99%
650 nm53.83%53.77%53.86%
850 nm54.14%54.11%54.19%
900 nm54.20%54.14%54.25%
910 nm54.14%54.09%54.20%
1000 nm54.16%54.09%54.29%
Table 2. Extract from the sample report, serial no. 22070. The full report lists every 10 nm from 380 to 1000 nm.

Check that the range on the report includes your lidar wavelength, then look at the data interval. The sample reports every 10 nm, so 905 nm sits between the 900 nm and 910 nm rows. It stops at 1000 nm. A 1550 nm lidar needs a report measured on an instrument that covers that band. If that is what you need, ask us for a 905 nm or 1550 nm sample report.

reflectance vs wavelength 380 1000nm sample
reflectance vs wavelength 380 1000nm sample

3. The measurement geometry is stated

The sample was measured with an 8° integrating sphere. Light strikes the surface at 8° from normal, and the sphere collects the reflection over the whole hemisphere. Hemispherical geometry is a standard spectrophotometric method, covered by ASTM E1331.

A lidar does not collect a hemisphere. It receives only the light that comes straight back along the beam. The two agree when the surface is close to Lambertian, meaning it scatters evenly in all directions. They drift apart if the surface has gloss or any retroreflective behaviour, and ASTM E1331 itself does not recommend hemispherical geometry for retroreflective materials when high accuracy is needed.

So check that the geometry is written on the report. If your test uses tilted targets, ask the supplier what angular data they have.

4. The reference standard and traceability are named

Reflectance is measured by comparison with a reference white. The report should name that reference and say who calibrated it.

NIST defines metrological traceability as a result that can be related to a reference “through a documented unbroken chain of calibrations, each contributing to the measurement uncertainty”. NIST adds that the provider of the result is responsible for supporting the claim. The word “traceable” with no named reference behind it is not enough.

In the sample, the reference white was calibrated by the National Institute of Metrology, China (NIM), and the method documents are listed by number.

5. Uniformity is measured, and the positions are shown

One reading at the centre says nothing about the corners. A lidar test uses points spread across the panel, as described in our guide to LiDAR target size, so the report should give readings at several positions and show where they are.

The sample uses nine positions in a 3 × 3 grid. It reports the lowest and the highest position against the mean of all nine.

ItemSerial no. 22070Serial no. 22071
Mean of 9 positions53.26%53.27%
Lowest position53.25%53.12%
Highest position53.27%53.38%
Deviation from the mean−0.01 / +0.01−0.15 / +0.11
Stated uniformity toleranceWithin ±1.5Within ±1.5
Table 3. Uniformity summary from the sample report (mean over 380–1000 nm, in reflectance points).

Nine points on a small target sit a few centimetres apart. On a 1.2 m panel they are much further apart, so for large targets ask for the grid layout before you order.

6. The tolerance is stated in units you can check

Tolerances get written in two ways. “±2%” can mean two reflectance points, so a 10% target may sit anywhere from 8% to 12%. It can also mean two percent of the value, which is 9.8% to 10.2%. On a 10% target the two readings differ by a factor of ten, and by more on darker targets.

The report should make clear which one applies and show the measured deviation next to the limit. In the sample, deviations are given in reflectance points: a 53.12% position against a 53.27% mean is listed as −0.15.

7. You know whether it is a calibration certificate or a test report

These are different documents. A calibration certificate from an ISO/IEC 17025 accredited laboratory reports a measurement uncertainty and states how the results are traceable, as A2LA’s guidance on certificates describes. A manufacturer’s test report shows the measured values and a pass or fail against the product tolerance. It may not state an uncertainty.

Both are useful. NIST makes the point that traceability alone does not make a result fit for purpose: the uncertainty has to be small enough for the measurement you are making. If your test plan has an accuracy budget, ask the supplier for the measurement uncertainty.

8. The date, conditions and handling notes are there

Coatings age and surfaces pick up dirt. A report should carry the test date and the ambient conditions (25 °C and 40% RH in the sample), and it should tell you how to handle and clean the surface. Set a re-measurement interval for your lab and count it from the report date.

CheckGood signWarning sign
1. Serial numberSame number on the report and the panel label“Typical” data with no serial number
2. WavelengthRange includes your laser; interval statedOne number with no wavelength; visible-only data for an NIR target
3. GeometryStated, for example 8° hemisphericalNot stated
4. TraceabilityReference standard and calibrating institute named“Traceable” with nothing behind it
5. UniformitySeveral positions, with a grid diagramA single centre reading
6. ToleranceUnits clear; measured value beside the limit“±x%” with no basis given
7. Document typeUncertainty stated, or given when you askNo answer when you ask
8. Date and conditionsTest date, temperature, humidityUndated
Table 4. Eight checks for a reflectance target test report.

What to Ask the Supplier Before You Order

The right report is easier to get before the order than after delivery. Put these five points in your request for quotation:

  • The reflectance value and the wavelengths it must be reported at, for example 905 nm and 1550 nm.
  • One report per panel, with serial numbers.
  • The number of measurement positions and the grid layout for your panel size.
  • The tolerance, stated in reflectance points.
  • A sample report in advance, so you can see the format before you commit.

How Calibvision Reports Reflectance Targets

Calibvision diffuse reflectance targets ship with a report for the individual unit. The sample used in this article shows the format: nine-point spectral data at 10 nm intervals, a uniformity summary, the reference standard and a conformance statement.

The sample covers 380–1000 nm on a small target. For lidar panels, reports are issued at the wavelengths you specify, including 905 nm and 1550 nm. If you would like to see a report for your wavelength and reflectance level before ordering, contact us and we will send a matching sample.

Related Reading

Picture of Ben Tsang

Popular Calibration Targets

Need a custom calibration target?

In This Article

0
0
Your Cart
Your cart is emptyReturn to Shop

Get Your Quote Now

Please fill out the form below or email us directly to sales@calibvision.com, our sales engineers will review your request and get back to you within 3 working days(typically faster).